Articles

No Bake Cookies Organic vs. Non-organic


For some reason I can’t make no bake cookies with organic ingredients. Does anyone know why? We made the same recipe for these cookies twice. Once with the organic ingredients I had on hand and the second time with the non-organic ingredients my friend had. Both batches of cookies were made in the same kitchen, with the same humidity level, same pots and pans; only a few of the ingredients were different. The organic cookies did not set up and were really gooey. The non-organic cookies were perfect.



No Bake Cookies

Organic

Non-organic

3 cups quick oats

Quaker quick oats

Quaker quick oats

2T cocoa

Ghirardelli

Ghirardelli

1 stick of margarine

Organic

Blue Bonnet

1/2 cup milk

Organic Valley 1%

Dairygold 1%

2 cups sugar

Organic

Western Family

1/2 cup peanut butter

Adams

Jif